Your browser is out-of-date!

Update your browser to view this website correctly. Update my browser now

×

Trade-In Interest Outpaces Retailer Offers Among U.S. Shoppers

Alchemy research finds 78% of consumers consider trade-in options, but only half were offered one during their most recent purchase

(image credit: Thinkstock)

Retailers may be missing an opportunity to drive upgrades and higher-value sales by overlooking trade-in options. New research from Alchemy finds that 78% of U.S. consumers consider trading in older products, but only half (50%) were offered the option during their most recent purchase.

The study, conducted by FDM CCS Insight across 11,217 consumers in the U.S., UK, Germany, and Poland, found that competitive trade-in values could influence both purchase decisions and spending. Nearly three-quarters (74%) of U.S. shoppers said a strong trade-in offer would make them more likely to choose a higher-end product, while 76% said they would upgrade sooner if their preferred brand offered attractive trade-in values.

The potential sales impact is significant. Nearly three-quarters (74%) of U.S. consumers said a competitive trade-in value would make them more likely to purchase a higher-end product than originally planned. Another 76% said they would upgrade sooner if their preferred brand offered attractive trade-in values, while 68% would be more inclined to add accessories, warranties or other products to their purchase.

Trade-in programs can also influence brand perception. Seven in 10 consumers (71%) said offering trade-in improves their opinion of a brand, with 44% citing the ability to make an upgrade feel more affordable as a primary benefit.

The findings suggest trade-in could play a larger role in premium product sales. A trade-in discount was the most frequently cited option for making a premium purchase or upgrade more accessible, selected by 37% of respondents. That compared with 29% who favored monthly payments and 21% who preferred subscription options.

However, simply offering a trade-in program may not be enough to drive participation. Consumers want competitive valuations and greater transparency about what their older devices are worth. More than one-quarter (27%) of U.S. respondents said trade-in values are currently too low, while 22% said those values aren’t clearly communicated. Another 21% said greater awareness of the residual value of older products would make them more likely to participate.

Trust and certainty also factor into the decision. Some 67% of respondents said a guaranteed price following an online trade-in quote would increase their confidence in a program. Another 64% said they would like the option to return a product if its final valuation differs from the original estimate.

“Trade-in has moved well beyond a sustainability initiative or a way to reduce the cost of a new device,” said Stephen Wise, director of global marketing at Alchemy. “It is now one of the clearest signals of how competitive a brand’s overall proposition is – and consumers are telling us they are prepared to choose, and stay with, the brands that get it right.”

Wise added that programs combining competitive valuations with transparency and flexibility could help brands attract customers, encourage repeat purchases and recover more devices for reuse.

Alchemy has published two free playbooks based on the research. One focuses on improving established trade-in programs, while the other offers guidance for brands looking to build participation in newer programs. Both are available through the company’s website at wearealchemy.com.

Research: The research was conducted by FDM CCS Insight on behalf of Alchemy. An online survey of 11,217 consumers was carried out across four markets – the UK, US, Germany and Poland (approximately 2,800 per market) – with fieldwork running from 8 to 27 July 2026. Respondents were surveyed across seven device categories: smartphones, smartwatches, tablets and e-readers, laptops and desktop computers, gaming and home entertainment, beauty and personal care electronics, and floor care. US figures are drawn from the US sample (approx. 2,800 respondents).

About Alchemy
Alchemy is a global leader in the circular technology sector, providing end-to-end circular solutions that drive sustainability, innovation, and transparency through each stage of the tech lifecycle. Recently winning the Deloitte Impact Award in association with Meta and ranking on its Technology Fast 50 Ireland list, Alchemy is trusted by over 3,000 partners in 60 markets and has successfully recovered, processed, and remarketed over 14 million devices.

With a commitment to reducing environmental impact, Alchemy operates through four specialist divisions: Circularity, Trading, Callisto, and Loop. Alchemy Circularity provides tailored lifecycle, reverse logistics, and recommerce solutions for OEMs, retailers, and carriers, supported by a proprietary tech infrastructure and global facilities network.

Visit wearealchemy.com for more information.

About FDM | CCS Insight
CCS Insight is a global analyst company providing valuable insights and analysis to navigate the complex technology landscape. It offers comprehensive services tailored to meet the individual needs of its clients, helping them make sense of the connected world and optimize their strategies. CCS Insight was recently acquired by FDM, a leading player in telecom pricing and market share insights, which is backed by private equity firm Inflexion. Learn more at: ccsinsight.com.

See also: Luxury Audio Market Forecast To Reach $3.4 Billion By 2030

Featured

Close