News Flash: TVs Might Fall Over
Warning! TVs and big pieces of furniture could tip over and hurt someone, so you better be careful.
That’s the message, more or less, that some New Jersey legislators want vendors to include in or on the packaging of TV sets with screens sizes of 25 inches and up, of any TV stand, and of furniture that’s 42 inches or more in height, including dressers, bookcases, and armoires used to “stores, display or otherwise place items.”
The bill passed the state Assembly’s consumer affairs committee, but a floor vote hasn’t been scheduled.
As amended by the committee, the bill “requires that consumers receive written notice concerning the existence of separately available devices designed to anchor, stabilize, or otherwise prevent large furniture or televisions from tipping,” according to an Assembly statement. The warning does not have to mention specific types of products that stabilize TV sets and furniture, as required in the original proposal.
The amended bill would also leave it to manufacturers to warn consumers about the tipping threat. Retailers would have had to hand out the warnings in the original proposal.
The bill specifies a civil penalty of up to $250 for a first offense or up to $500 for each subsequent offense.
Assembly Bill No. 2230 is designed with the best of intentions. It’s designated as Chloe and Samantha’s Law in memory of two girls killed in unfortunate TV-tipping accidents. On December 17, 2006, in Vineland, New Jersey, a 27-inch television fell on top of 18-month-old Chloe Keiser. Another girl, 35-month-old Samantha Ventresca of Lawrence Township, died May 9, 2007, when a similarly large television fell off a bureau that had tipped over.
I doubt the bill will save lives. You can’t legislate common sense, or watch your kids every moment of the day to make sure they’re not climbing on furniture.
The only solution might be to force consumers to bolt their TV sets and furniture to the floor.
What’s your take on this?
AnnaHopn commented:
Hi, Interesting, I`ll quote it on my site later. Have a nice day
AnnaHopn commented:
Charlie commented:
Hi there, Interesting, I`ll quote it on my site later. Have a nice
day Charlie
Charlie commented:
Dirnov commented:
Dirnov commented:
Hi, Thanks for article. Everytime like to read you. Thank you
Dirnov
parent of four commented:
parent of four commented:
How about a bill to fund parent education before children are born,
rather than on individual things they may encounter afterwards. How
about mandatory classes on how to childproof a home at a hospital
or pre-natal care center? I didn't learn to not use a hair dryer in
the bathtub from reading the label, I saw a PSA or maybe it was
Sesame Street. Or here's an idea for retailers. Put some securing
methods on the sales floor next to the big items and train your
sales people to cross-sell. Websites, likewise. I bought a 50" LCD
from CCity and was told about the joys of expensive HDMI cables,
etc, but nothing about straps. I bought 5 7-foot bookcases in CA
and the salesperson thoughtfully talked to me about earthquake
straps. I bought a bunch from him, though I could have bought them
from the local hardware store, later.
jecjckeiser commented:
The law will not go after a parent that has gone through this
unless it was done with intent there are such things as accidents
but with this paper it might save a life so is it really going to
kill all of you to have one piece of paper in the box?????? You all
must not have a child.... I have 5 and would do anything to protect
them encluding child proofing my home that was done be for the
accident happened in our home. You all just need to think of the
other kids that parents that have no idea of the dangers not worry
what law will be passed.
jecjckeiser commented:
jecjckeiser commented:
jecjckeiser commented:
Look I am sick of all of this the only thing that we are trying to
do is let parents know of the dangers that is all this law will not
make you use any of the straps it just tells of the warnings like a
hair dryer has..... If i or any of the other 175 parents knew we
would have taken every measure to protect our child. so again
thankyou for reading this and helping in protecting our children
Chloe's mommy
A parent commented:
This comment was deleted because it did not meet TWICE standards.
A parent commented:
CBR1234 commented:
Just another stupid law to protect the idiots from hurting
themselves.Lets throw them another safety net. Anyone who is small
enough for this to effect probably can not read yet,and lack of
common sense by anyone else will not be decided by a law.
CBR1234 commented:
TV DUDE commented:
TV DUDE commented:
The 27" TV was on a stand. Does anyone have a picture of the stand
and TV? I'd really like to see the set-up that killed this little
girl.
Rich commented:
Rich commented:
Anything is going to tip over given enough weight or unbalance. I'm
sorry about the kids that might have been hurt or killed from a
fall, but this is total absurdity. You can't legislate or warn
someone enough when it comes to accidents. If a product has been
designed in a way where it falls over with little to no force, then
the attorneys can line up to sue the manufacturers for the
defective product. In this case, I'm sure the engineers designed
the product to hold most sets without the unit falling over. Why
are we as a people accepting these insane laws? Why?
Beach Boy commented:
Beach Boy commented:
What New Jersey has come out with a new law before California. Just
wait tell our politicians get wind of this !
Visual Technology commented:
My condolances to those who have suffered. For one, I think the
lawmakers waste way to much time digging up reasons to make such
laws. There cannot be a law for everything. Where does it end? Next
we will have home inspections and citations for a dirty shirt on
the floor. Someone could trip and break their head. Come on folks!
If you have small children, do something about that wobbly tv, or
your nick nacks set on the edge of a shelf. Even if you dont have
kids. I dont want my tv to fall on the floor! duh. But we cant
protect the world from the world with a million laws.
Visual Technology commented:
FridayBob commented:
FridayBob commented:
"always watch your child every second"?? How realistic is that? Be
a responsible parent and childproof your home. This proposed
legislation is just a way to punish parents after the fact, at a
time when they are emotionally distraught and crushed with grief.
Next thing you know, we'll all be required to put plastic caps on
the electrical outlets and child locks on every cabinet. Those of
you with children should do that anyway, but making it a law is
just stupid. Who will enforce it; the house police?
chloe''s mom commented:
always watch your child every second. My daughter got up early in
the morning and we didn’
chloe''s mom commented:
jecjckeiser@comcast.net commented:
First I would like to thank you for writing this beautiful article.
I am Chloe's mom and the reason I am writing this is yes everyone
is entitled to their own opinion on this matter and that is great
but as a parent you can’
jecjckeiser@comcast.net commented:



















